feat: consider plugin-system

@gleamish

As suggested by @gleamish and continuing on issue #24 maybe it would be interesting to consider a plugin-system to enrich what is contained in useThree and how the props of T are resolved.

API I had in mind:

// solid-three.ts
import { createT, Interactivity } from "solid-three"
import { DreiPlugin } from "solid-drei"
import { BoxGeometry, Mesh, MeshBasicMaterial } from "three"

export const { Canvas, T, extend } = createT({ BoxGeometry, Mesh, MeshBasicMaterial }, [DreiPlugin, Interactivity])

// app.ts
import { Canvas, T } from "./solid-three.ts"
import { render } from "solid-js/web"

render(() => <Canvas><T.Mesh onClick={console.log}><T.BoxGeometry/><T.MeshBasicMaterial/></T.Mesh></Canvas>, document.getElementById('app'))

prior art: https://threlte.xyz/docs/learn/advanced/plugins

One of the concerns I have for the plugin-system is how it would interact with third party solid-three components:

how can you create components if you are not sure what props they will have (or how those props will behave)?
if the prop resolution is handled in the root-component <Canvas/>, it could also extend external components, but how can you type them dynamically?

threlte opts for using context to inject the plugins and augmenting module namespaces to set the prop types. These 2 approaches are fundamentally at odds in my opinion, as context is about scoping and augmenting module namespaces are global. That being said, in 99.9999% of the user-projects there will only be a single threejs context, so it's not bad to have it as an option.

I am not sure how threlte handles typechecking external components if the props they use are actually valid in the project, but I was thinking of something like this:

from my-lib

Library authors would need to make their components generic

import { Entity, type Plugin } from "solid-three"

export function Box<T extends Plugin<{ onMouseDown(...): ... }>>(props: ...){
    return <Entity<T> from={...} onMouseDown={props.onMouseDown}  />
}

The generic extends from Plugin<{ ... }> defining all the non-standard props that the component makes use of.

user project

// t.ts
import { createT, EventPlugin, type Plugin } from "solid-three"

const plugins = [EventPlugin] satisfies Plugin[]
export type Plugin = typeof plugins

export const { T, Canvas } = createT(THREE, plugins)

// App.tsx
import { type Plugin, Canvas } from "./t.ts"
import { Box } from "my-lib"

return <Canvas>
  <Box<Plugin> onMouseDown={console.log} />
</Canvas>

It's a bit of plumbing, but it would give you type-security.

A QOL idea would be that you can pass your external components in the createT-call, this way they could be typechecked at the declaration and <Box<Plugin> /> can become <T.Box />:

// t.ts
import { Box } from "my-lib"
import { createT, EventPlugin, type Plugin } from "solid-three"

const plugins = [EventPlugin] satisfies Plugin[]
export type Plugin = typeof plugins

export const { T, Canvas } = createT({ ... THREE, Box }, plugins)

// App.tsx
import { T, Canvas } from "./t.ts"

return <Canvas>
  <T.Box onMouseDown={console.log} />
</Canvas>

The same can be done for <Entity<Plugin> /> 👉 <T.Entity />

Maybe it could fallback to the namespace if no generic is passed

my-lib

import { Entity, type S3 } from "solid-three"

export function Box<T extends S3.Plugin<{ ... }> = $3.DefaultPlugin>(props: ...){
    return <Entity<T> from={...} onMouseDown={props.onMouseDown}  />
}

user code

import { Box } from "my-lib"
import { Canvas } from "./t.ts"

declare global {
  namespace $3 {
    interface Props {
      onMouseDown(event: MouseEvent): void 
    }
  }
}

return <Canvas>
  <Box onMouseDown={console.log} />
</Canvas>

Another option would be to follow in threlte's footsteps and also allow to scope plugins via context-scope:

import { Entity, type S3, PluginProvider } from "solid-three"
import { EventPlugin } from "solid-drei"

export function Box(props: ...){
    return <PluginProvider plugins={[EventPlugin]}>
        <Entity from={...} onMouseDown={props.onMouseDown}  />
    </PluginProvider>
}

Then you are also assured that the props your component relies upon are being handled as you would expect.
Or add a plugins-prop for complete granular control?

import { Entity, type S3, PluginProvider } from "solid-three"
import { EventPlugin } from "solid-drei"

export function Box(props: ...){
    return <Entity from={...} onMouseDown={props.onMouseDown}  plugins={[EventPlugin]} />
}

Question is then: how do these interact with plugins defined in createT(..., [...plugins])?

Question is then: how do these interact with plugins defined in createT(..., [...plugins])?

Some pseudo code

my-lib

import { createT, Entity, type S3 } from "solid-three"
import { Mesh } from "three"

function MyLibPlugin(element){
    return {
        onMouseDown: (callback) => callback('lib')
    }
}

const { T, Canvas } = createT(THREE, [MyLibPlugin])

export function Box(props: S3.Props<Mesh>){
    return <T.Mesh onMouseDown={console.log} {...props} />
}

export function BareBox<T>(props: S3.Props<Mesh>){
    return <Entity<T> from={Mesh} {...props} />
}

user code

import { Box, BareBox } from "my-lib"
import { createT } from "solid-three"

function Plugin1(element){
    return {
        onMouseDown: (callback) => callback('user 1')
    }
}
function Plugin2(element){
    return {
        onMouseDown: (callback) => callback('user 2')
    }
}

const { T, Canvas } = createT(THREE, [Plugin1])

return <Canvas>
    {/* logs 'user 1' */}
    <T.Mesh onMouseDown={console.log} /> 
    {/* logs 'user 2' */}
    <T.Mesh onMouseDown={console.log} plugins={[Plugin2]} />
    {/* logs 'lib' */}
    <Box onMouseDown={console.log} />
    {/* logs 'user 2' */}
    <Box onMouseDown={console.log} plugins={[Plugin2]} />
    {/* logs 'user 1' */}
    <BareBox<typeof T> onMouseDown={console.log} />
    {/* logs 'user 2' */}
    <BareBox<typeof T> onMouseDown={console.log} plugins={[Plugin2]} />
</Canvas>

This is how I imagine it: cascading over multiple levels.

Base layer is the <Canvas/>-context 👉 components mount in <Canvas/> will fall back to resolving their props according to the plugins defined in createT. This includes external components. (?)
- if in createT(..., [plugin1, plugin2]) plugin1 and plugin2 try to handle the same prop, the last wins (?)
All entities defined with createT and accessed via T. have their props resolved via the plugins defined in createT. This allows for libraries to define their own T for internal use.
Every <Entity /> and <T. /> component has a plugins-prop, in which they can pass plugins too. If a property is defined these will take preference.

The fact that it is also distributed over context is a bit awkward as

import { Box } from "my-lib"
const box = <Box/>
return <Canvas>{box}</Canvas>

and

import { Box } from "my-lib"
return <Canvas><Box/></Canvas>

will have different ways of resolving their prop...
but context is a bit awkward in general, so ye.

Navigation Menu

Repository navigation

feat: consider plugin-system #32

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Type

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

feat: consider plugin-system #32

Description

Activity

bigmistqke commented on Aug 4, 2025

bigmistqke commented on Aug 24, 2025

bigmistqke commented on Aug 24, 2025

bigmistqke commented on Aug 24, 2025

bigmistqke commented on Aug 24, 2025

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Type

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

Issue actions