Summary
unitIsClaimable has a question guard (if (u.includes("?")) return false;), but it can never fire: splitIntoUnits splits on [.!?;,]+ and consumes the ?, so every unit reaches the guard without it. A statement-shaped question is typed as a claim.
Repro (public main @ 5e2f2e8, LifeOS/install/hooks/VerificationGate.hook.ts)
import { classifyClaim, splitIntoUnits } from "./hooks/VerificationGate.hook";
splitIntoUnits("The site is live?"); // ["The site is live"] — "?" gone
classifyClaim("The site is live?")?.type; // "T1"
classifyClaim("The deploy succeeded, the site is live?")?.type; // "T1"
classifyClaim("Is the site live?")?.type; // null (caught by LEADING_INTERROGATIVE, not by the "?" guard)English mostly hides this because questions usually start with an interrogative word or inverted verb. In languages where a yes/no question keeps statement word order and is marked only by "?" (Portuguese, Spanish, Italian: "O site está no ar?"), the "?" is the only signal, and it is lost before the guard runs. ISACloseGate's completionUnit shares splitIntoUnits, so "Done?" style questions hit the same path there.
Suggested fix (one line)
Drop the interrogative clause before the split, so a question never becomes a unit:
return text
.replace(/[^\n.!?]*\?/g, "\n")
.split(/\n+|(?<!\d)[.!?;,]+|[.!?;,]+(?!\d)/)
The clause is taken from the previous terminator to the "?", so a statement sitting before the question in the same message ("The site is live. Want me to check login?") is still read as a claim. Applied locally with tests for both cases; the existing hook suite stays green.
Summary
unitIsClaimablehas a question guard (if (u.includes("?")) return false;), but it can never fire:splitIntoUnitssplits on[.!?;,]+and consumes the?, so every unit reaches the guard without it. A statement-shaped question is typed as a claim.Repro (public
main@ 5e2f2e8,LifeOS/install/hooks/VerificationGate.hook.ts)English mostly hides this because questions usually start with an interrogative word or inverted verb. In languages where a yes/no question keeps statement word order and is marked only by "?" (Portuguese, Spanish, Italian: "O site está no ar?"), the "?" is the only signal, and it is lost before the guard runs. ISACloseGate's
completionUnitsharessplitIntoUnits, so "Done?" style questions hit the same path there.Suggested fix (one line)
Drop the interrogative clause before the split, so a question never becomes a unit:
The clause is taken from the previous terminator to the "?", so a statement sitting before the question in the same message ("The site is live. Want me to check login?") is still read as a claim. Applied locally with tests for both cases; the existing hook suite stays green.