You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
As an OpenShell operator, I want policy updates accepted for a running sandbox to be applied live by its active compute runtime, so that the policy reported by the gateway always matches the policy the workload is actually enforcing.
Problem Statement
PR #2823 gives driver-controlled runtimes the canonical create-time policy in DriverSandboxSpec.policy and removes the MXC-specific rejection for live policy mutations. The MXC backend reads and maps that policy only during ValidateSandboxCreate and CreateSandbox; it does not fetch later revisions or report their load status.
The gateway can therefore accept and persist a later policy revision for a running driver-controlled sandbox without the runtime consuming it. The desired policy returned by the gateway then differs from the policy enforced by the workload.
The existing sandbox configuration contract already exposes later revisions through GetSandboxConfig and load acknowledgement through ReportPolicyStatus. This bug does not require a compute-driver reconcile RPC.
Impact / Why This Matters
A tightening update can appear accepted while the workload continues under the previous policy. A loosening update remains unavailable even though the gateway records it. --wait can time out because the driver never reports the revision as loaded.
The current workaround is to delete and recreate the sandbox so the policy is delivered again at creation. That interrupts the workload, discards runtime state, and violates the expected live policy-update workflow.
Acceptance Criteria
A driver-controlled runtime without the standard supervisor observes every new effective policy revision for each running sandbox.
The runtime applies supported live policy changes without deleting or recreating the sandbox.
The runtime calls ReportPolicyStatus with the exact revision and reports loaded only after enforcement has switched to that revision.
A load or enforcement failure is reported as failed and is visible through openshell policy status and --wait.
A policy change the selected runtime cannot enforce live is rejected before it can be mistaken for an applied revision.
Reconnects, gateway restarts, and temporarily missed notifications converge the runtime to the latest effective revision.
Tests cover successful live application, rejected unsupported changes, failed application, acknowledgement, and catch-up after reconnect/restart.
MXC documentation no longer claims live revision support unless the MXC runtime implements and validates this behavior.
Create and start an MXC sandbox with a policy that the driver maps successfully.
Submit an otherwise valid live policy replacement or merge update with openshell policy set --wait or openshell policy update --wait.
Observe that the gateway persists the new revision, while MxcComputeBackend continues using only the policy captured during CreateSandbox and never acknowledges the later revision.
Observe that --wait cannot confirm the revision as loaded and the running workload remains governed by its create-time policy.
User Story
As an OpenShell operator, I want policy updates accepted for a running sandbox to be applied live by its active compute runtime, so that the policy reported by the gateway always matches the policy the workload is actually enforcing.
Problem Statement
PR #2823 gives driver-controlled runtimes the canonical create-time policy in
DriverSandboxSpec.policyand removes the MXC-specific rejection for live policy mutations. The MXC backend reads and maps that policy only duringValidateSandboxCreateandCreateSandbox; it does not fetch later revisions or report their load status.The gateway can therefore accept and persist a later policy revision for a running driver-controlled sandbox without the runtime consuming it. The desired policy returned by the gateway then differs from the policy enforced by the workload.
The existing sandbox configuration contract already exposes later revisions through
GetSandboxConfigand load acknowledgement throughReportPolicyStatus. This bug does not require a compute-driver reconcile RPC.Impact / Why This Matters
A tightening update can appear accepted while the workload continues under the previous policy. A loosening update remains unavailable even though the gateway records it.
--waitcan time out because the driver never reports the revision as loaded.The current workaround is to delete and recreate the sandbox so the policy is delivered again at creation. That interrupts the workload, discards runtime state, and violates the expected live policy-update workflow.
Acceptance Criteria
ReportPolicyStatuswith the exact revision and reportsloadedonly after enforcement has switched to that revision.openshell policy statusand--wait.Reproduction Steps
openshell policy set --waitoropenshell policy update --wait.MxcComputeBackendcontinues using only the policy captured duringCreateSandboxand never acknowledges the later revision.--waitcannot confirm the revision as loaded and the running workload remains governed by its create-time policy.Environment
d26297a214b40809e4b4dfcd5513e3e257b0552copenshell-driver-mxc, without the standard sandbox supervisorRelated Work